Best Muskoka Chairs

Post Summary: Are you looking for a new chair for the cottage, cabin, or home? We’re breaking down the Muskoka chair vs Adirondack chair, is there actually a difference? and a quick buyer’s guide of the best!

When it comes to the quintessential cottage chair there are two styles that come to mind: the Muskoka chair and the Adirondack chair. Although at first glance these two seem strikingly similar, there are nuanced differences that set them apart. If you’re debating which chair to pick for your garden, lakeside retreat, or patio, here’s a breakdown that may help you make an informed decision.

As someone who grew up visiting the cottage every weekend, I basically lived in our Muskoka and Adirondack chairs. There are slight differences which we will break down below, but also a lot of similarities. So keep reading because we had fun exploring the history and orgins of these two key pieces in cottage culture.

Keep reading as we break down the differences between the Muskoka chair vs Adirondack chair, our take, and what the best chair for you to purchase is.

Muskoka Chair vs Adirondack Chair

The Muskoka chair and the Adirondack chair are similar in many ways but do have distinct differences that set them apart. At first glance, the design elements look quite similar—both have slanted backrests, deep seats, and wide armrests designed for outdoor comfort. However, when you delve into the specifics, the differences become apparent.

• One significant distinction is the height of the chairs. Muskoka chairs typically have a seat height that is about two inches lower than that of Adirondack chairs. This slight difference in height can be particularly useful for people who may have difficulty getting in and out of chairs, such as the elderly or those with mobility issues. A lower seat height can make it easier to sit down and stand up, thereby providing a more accessible seating option.

• Another difference lies in the curvature of the backrest and the width of the armrests. Muskoka chairs often have a more contoured back, while Adirondack chairs usually feature a steeper, straighter back. The armrests on an Adirondack chair are generally wider, offering more space for setting down items like drinks or books. On the other hand, Muskoka chairs have somewhat narrower armrests but often feature a deeper seat for a different kind of comfort.

So, while both chairs offer a relaxed and comfortable outdoor seating option, your choice between a Muskoka and an Adirondack may come down to specific needs and preferences, such as ease of getting in and out of the chair, or the kind of back and armrest comfort you desire.

The History of The Muskoka Chair and Adirondack Chair

Adirondack Chair

The Adirondack chair takes its name from the Adirondack Mountains in the state of New York, where it was invented in the early 20th century. Its primary aim was to offer a simple yet comfortable chair, designed using 11 pieces of wood, that people could easily build themselves.

Muskoka Chair

The Muskoka chair, on the other hand, is named after the picturesque Muskoka region in Ontario, Canada. Although both designs originated from the need for practical, comfortable outdoor seating, the Muskoka chair is very much a Canadian symbol and is more prevalent in Canada.

The Design of Both Chairs

Backrest

Both the Adirondack and Muskoka chairs have slanted backrests, but the back slats in an Adirondack chair are typically straight and offer a somewhat steeper recline. Muskoka chairs generally have a more gently curved back, contributing to a slightly different sitting posture.

Seat

The seats in both chairs are slanted to allow for relaxed seating. However, Muskoka chairs often have a deeper seat, providing a different kind of comfort as compared to the shallower but wider seat of the Adirondack chair.

Armrests

The armrests of an Adirondack chair are usually wider and flatter, offering ample space for your arms and even a beverage or book. Muskoka chairs also have flat armrests, but they tend to be a bit narrower.

Material

Traditionally, both chair types were made of wood, but today you can find variations made of plastic, metal, or composite materials. Cedar, pine, and teak are popular choices for wooden versions.

Practical Considerations

Portability

If you plan on moving your chairs frequently, you may find that Muskoka chairs are generally lighter and slightly more portable due to their less bulky design.

Weather Resistance

Both types of chairs can withstand outdoor conditions well, especially if you choose weather-resistant materials or finishes. However, since Adirondack chairs are often made with thicker boards, they may fare slightly better in extreme conditions.

Aesthetics

Both chairs offer a rustic, laid-back appearance, but the choice between them often boils down to regional or personal aesthetic preferences.

Customizations and Variations

Both Muskoka and Adirondack chairs have seen various design adaptations over the years, including versions with built-in footrests, cup holders, and even rocking chair functionalities.

Price Point

The pricing is generally similar for both types, although Adirondack chairs can sometimes be more expensive due to the use of more substantial materials.

What to Think About Before Purchasing

When it comes to outdoor chairs there are several things you should look for before you make a purchase. We want to be savvy, well-informed shoppers. So it’s important to go through these 8 questions before making a purchase.

1. What is the quality of the material? is the chair made from wood? cheap plastic? or hard resin?
2. How well was it made? is the chair held together by screws? or glue?
3. Are there any noticeable defects?
4. Is it sturdy? We sit on the chair that is set up in the store, if possible. We’ve seen people break a leg on plastic chairs many times.
5. Check the comfort level. Take a seat, lean back, and make sure you can get out of the chair. Some Muskoka chairs are really low, and some are too deep. Making it really hard to get back up.
6. Is the chair heavy? Do you need it to stay outdoors for the summer? or will you bring it indoors or in storage when you’re not using it?
7. If it’s a plastic chair, is it affordable?
8. Or if it’s made from hard resin or wood, will it last for years?

The Best Muskoka Chairs and Adirondack Chairs

These are our favorite chairs from Amazon!

I hope this helps you narrow down some quality and durable Muskoka chairs for your cottage, cabin, or even your backyard! I specifically choose items we have had for years or our friends have had for years. Let me know if there are any you would add to the list!

Whether you opt for the Muskoka chair or the Adirondack chair, you’re investing in a piece of furniture that embodies leisure, relaxation, and a love for the outdoors.

The best chair for you ultimately depends on your specific needs, aesthetic preferences, and how you plan to use the chair. If you’re in Canada or have a love for Canadian culture, a Muskoka chair might resonate more with you.

Conversely, if you’re located in the United States or are drawn to the classic American outdoor lifestyle, an Adirondack chair could be the better fit. Regardless of your choice, both chairs offer a timeless and comfortable way to enjoy your outdoor space.